7 MORE Offensive Mistakes Well-Intentioned Writers Make


Getting Mental Illnesses & Different Neurologies Wrong

Want to create a chilling plot twist? Just the killer the hero's evil alternate personality! That's called schizophrenia... right?

Wrong. And this type of thing is incredibly insensitive and offensive.

Aside from the fact that schizophrenia does not create multiple personalities, most people with schizophrenia and multiple personalities are quite harmless. Yet thanks to their portrayal in fiction, many people expect them to be dangerous, which makes their already-difficult lives even more difficult.

Occasionally, some people go the other direction and portray these people as innocent or even mystical. That's positive discrimination, and that's also bad because it creates unrealistic expectations.

Whether it's schizophrenia, multiple personlities, autism, Asperger's, psychopathy, sociopathy, or anything else, you're going to use a mental disorder or alternate neurology of any kind, make sure you research it. And whatever you do, NEVER give your character a mental illness just to make xir more "interesting," because that's ableism.


Trying to Create an Aesop About Discrimination Without Actually Understanding the Discrimination in Question

Most people think they have a pretty good bead on what racism is all about - it's about segregation, ugly slurs, and pointy white hats. Same goes with sexism - women can get jobs and vote now, so it must be over, right? Ha, if only.

In real life, these people are very rarely overt - in fact, most racism is extremely subtle, so subtle that the offender doesn't even realize that what they've said or done is offensive or hurtful and will vehemently deny the possiblity that what they said or did could have been offensive. (A common response from these people is "I can't be an X-ist! I have X friends!" Yeah, if only.)

Some examples of subtle discrimination:

If you want to learn more about what real discrimination of all kinds look and feel like, I recommend reading Microaggressions. (Language warning.) Also, check out this handy-dandy list of links to privilege checklists so you can get a bead on some issues of inequality before writing off into the sunset.


Trying to Satirize a Thing Without Understanding Why it's a Thing

The film Death Becomes Her satirizes the perceived vanity of performers who spend mind-blowing amounts of money on beauty products and plastic surgeries to stay young. Funny film? Yes. But it's rather sexist in that it treats this perceived vanity as something that just happens to some women for no real reason. It ignores the fact that we live in a society obsessed with youth and that our consumerist culture has commodified it and tries to make us feel inferior every day for not buying it from them. It ignores the fact that the executives in control of the entertainment industry constantly pressure women into getting plastic surgery and enhancements, even flat-out refusing to hire women who don't meet their exact standards of beauty, regardless of their talent.


Killing Off GSRM/LGBT Characters to Make an Allegedly Non-Hateful Point

There's this thing that some writers do - they introduce an GSRM/LGBT character, try to build some some sympathy for xir, and before you know it they've killed off this character in a manner that's reminiscent of that old and noxious "too good for this sinful Earth" trope that pervaded Puritan literature.

This sends an absolutely terrible message to GSRM/LGBT people - that the only way they can escape the shame and the hate that so often comes with being GSRM/LGBT is if they die. GSRM/LGBT youth are at a higher risk of committing suicide already - clearly, this is not a message we want to be sending.


Forgetting Non-White Women in Female-Oriented Entertainment

Buffy the Vampire Slayer. Charmed. Pan Am. Sex in the City. All of these female-aimed shows exhibit distinctly monochrome casting choices. Sure, Charmed was sort of justified in that the three leads were supposed to be sisters. But Pan Am has no excuse - and there were plenty of non-white stewardesses in the 60's.


Multi-Racial Groups Always With a White at the Helm

This wouldn't be a problem if it didn't keep happening all the time. But invariably, whenever there's a multi-racial group or team of some kind, the leader will invariably be white. The implication is that while non-whites are good enough to have on a team, they still aren't leadership material.


The Fairytale Gypsy

You know the character type - they live in wagons, wear colorful clothing, read fortunes, and play a mean fiddle.

The trouble is, what you see in fiction is a romanticized version of a very ugly reality: "Gypsy" is actually a racial slur for the Roma and Dom people. The reason they're nomads is because people have a habit of routing them out whenever they try to settle down due to racial prejudices, and their eclectic fashion comes from having to wear whatever they can get. Also, they're no more magical than you or me.

Their portrayal in many fantasies perpetuates the myth that these people are fairytale creatures who vanished along with Long Ago And Far Away, rather than real people who suffer systemic oppression today.


See Also:

7 Offensive Mistakes Well-Intentioned Writers Make
Basic Tips To Get More Racial Diversity In Your Writing
Basic Tips To Avoid Tokenism
Basic Tips To Write Subcultures & Minority Religions Better



Back to Responsible & Socially-Conscious Writing
Go to a random page!